If you love personalizing your gear, you’ve likely heard of Best Ever Pads. Their biggest claim to fame is the incredible level of customization they offer. With over 40 leather colors, custom embroidery, and unique accents like fringe and crystals, you can design a pad that perfectly matches your style. But these pads are about much more than just good looks. The ability to choose the right wool type, thickness, and even add liners means you can create a pad tailored to your horse’s specific conformation and needs. This guide will walk you through all the options, helping you build a pad that’s not only a statement piece but also a high-performance tool in your tack room.
Key Takeaways
- Solve Fit Issues with Customization: Best Ever Pads shine when you need a specific solution for your horse's back or want to create a unique look. Use their different wool collections and extensive color options to build a pad that provides targeted support and matches your personal style.
- Understand the Performance Trade-Offs: While many riders love the soft, flexible feel right out of the box, others have concerns about long-term durability compared to firmer pads. Consider your riding intensity and how you prioritize immediate comfort versus rugged longevity.
- Choose Your Buying Path Wisely: For a fully personalized design with custom logos, order directly from the manufacturer. For a standard pad with fast, free shipping and the security of a 365-day satisfaction guarantee, purchase from an authorized retailer like Hooves and Paws.
What Makes Best Ever Pads a Rider Favorite?
When you talk to riders who use Best Ever Pads, you’ll hear a few themes over and over: comfort for the horse, durability, and a perfect fit. It’s not just hype. These pads are thoughtfully designed from the ground up with the horse’s anatomy in mind. They combine smart features, high-quality materials, and American craftsmanship to create a piece of horse tack that truly stands out. Let’s break down exactly what makes these pads a go-to choice for equestrians across disciplines.
A Smart Two-Piece Design with Wither Relief
One of the first things you'll notice about a Best Ever Pad is its unique shape. The two-piece, contoured design isn't just for looks; it's made to follow the natural curve of your horse's back. This thoughtful construction includes a generous cutout over the withers—that bony ridge between the shoulder blades. This simple feature makes a world of difference by preventing the pinching and pressure that can cause soreness. The pad is also shaped to accommodate the cinch, ensuring your saddle stays securely in place without shifting or rubbing, giving your horse the freedom to move comfortably.
Handmade with Premium Wool
Every Best Ever Pad is handmade to order in the USA, and the quality of the materials is a huge part of their appeal. They are crafted from 100% wool, a material prized for its natural benefits. Wool is incredibly breathable and wicks moisture away, which helps keep your horse cool and dry, even during long rides. It also provides excellent shock absorption, protecting your horse’s back from impact. Because each pad is made by hand with high-quality wool and leather, you get a product built with care and attention to detail.
Quality You Can Trust: Made in the USA
For many riders, knowing their gear is made in the USA is a significant mark of quality. Best Ever Pads takes this to heart, ensuring every pad meets high standards of craftsmanship. This commitment means you can trust that the pad you receive is built for performance and longevity. The focus on domestic manufacturing allows for better quality control, so you can feel confident that the pad’s design, from its contoured shape to its wither relief, is consistently executed to protect your horse and provide lasting comfort ride after ride.
Ready to Ride, Right Out of the Box
There’s nothing worse than stiff, new tack that needs a long break-in period. Best Ever Pads solves this problem. Thanks to the high-quality, 100% needle-punched wool used in pads like the popular OG, they are soft and flexible from day one. You get excellent compression protection and a comfortable fit for your horse immediately, without any awkward "getting to know you" phase. You can pull it out of the box, tack up, and head out for a ride knowing your horse is comfortable from the start.
How Can You Customize Your Best Ever Pad?
If you love making your gear your own, you’re in the right place. One of the biggest draws of Best Ever Pads is the incredible level of customization. It’s not just about getting a high-performance pad; it’s about creating something that reflects your personal style and your horse’s needs. From the color of the leather to the type of wool, you get to call the shots. This is your chance to design a piece of horse tack that’s as unique as your partnership with your horse, ensuring you stand out for all the right reasons. Let’s walk through all the ways you can build your perfect pad from the ground up.
Pick from Over 40 Leather Colors
Forget being stuck with standard black or brown. Best Ever Pads lets you express yourself with a massive selection of over 40 leather colors for the wear leathers. Whether you want to perfectly match your saddle, coordinate with your show outfit, or just pick your absolute favorite color, the choice is yours. This level of personalization is a huge part of what makes them the king of custom saddle pads. This splash of color is a fantastic way to add personality to your gear, turning a functional piece of equipment into a statement piece that’s uniquely you and feels truly special every time you tack up.
Select the Right Wool for Your Horse
Customization goes beyond looks—it’s also about your horse’s comfort. Best Ever Pads understands that every horse is different, which is why they offer several wool options. You can choose the specific thickness and type of wool that will give your horse the best support and fit. For even more fine-tuning, you can add a neoprene or fleece lining. This focus on a customized fit ensures the pad works with your horse’s conformation, providing comfort and protection where it’s needed most. It’s a thoughtful approach that shows a deep understanding of equine needs, whether you’re on a long trail ride or in a high-stakes performance arena.
Add Personal Designs and Embroidery
If you want a pad that’s truly one-of-a-kind, you can add personal designs and embroidery. This is perfect for adding your initials, your horse’s name, or even your ranch brand. Best Ever Pads offers beautiful options like intricate tooled leather, hand-painted designs, and unique cowhide accents that add texture and character. It’s an excellent way to create a meaningful keepsake or a professional-looking award for your next event. These custom award pads are popular for a reason—they combine top-tier function with a deeply personal touch that you just can’t get off the shelf.
Choose Your Edge: Fringe, Crystals, and More
The final flourish is all in the details. Best Ever Pads lets you finish your design with a variety of decorative edges. You can go for a classic, clean look or add some flair with options like leather fringe or sparkling crystals. With so many styles to choose from, you can create a pad that’s as subtle or as flashy as you want it to be. Each pad is handcrafted right here in the USA, so you know you’re getting a quality piece built to your exact specifications. It’s the perfect way to complete your custom saddle pad and hit the arena in style.
How Do Best Ever Pads Stack Up Against Competitors?
When you’re investing in a high-quality saddle pad, you want to be sure you’re making the right choice. The world of premium horse tack is full of excellent options, and Best Ever pads are frequently compared to other industry leaders, most notably 5 Star Equine. Both brands have dedicated followings, and the "best" one often comes down to your horse's needs and your personal preferences in the saddle.
Riders often weigh factors like wool quality, durability, fit, and overall feel. While Best Ever is known for its customization and slightly softer feel right out of the box, brands like 5 Star have built a reputation on rugged durability. Understanding what fellow equestrians are saying about these pads can help you see beyond the marketing and decide which one truly fits your riding style and long-term goals. We’ve gathered feedback from riders across different disciplines to give you a clear picture of how these pads perform in the real world.
Best Ever vs. 5 Star and Other Top Brands
The most common comparison you'll see is between Best Ever and 5 Star pads. Many riders own both and have a good feel for the differences. One rider mentioned, "Best Ever is a bit softer and more flexible," which can be a huge plus if you want a pad that conforms quickly to your horse's back. On the other hand, some riders prefer the firm, dense feel of a 5 Star pad, with one user noting, "I love mine, it is durable tough, still looks great." The choice often boils down to whether you prioritize a softer, more pliable feel or a tougher, more rigid construction for maximum support.
A Look at Durability and Long-Term Value
Durability is a major talking point when comparing these pads. While Best Ever pads are slightly more affordable upfront, some riders have raised concerns about their longevity. One potential buyer shared, "I've heard that Best Ever doesn't last long... I really don't want to custom order this pad and it not fit or last!" Another rider stated more directly, "They don't hold up." This suggests a potential trade-off: a lower initial cost might mean a shorter lifespan compared to some competitors. When considering long-term value, it's important to weigh how much use the pad will get and if you're willing to replace it sooner.
What Riders Love (and What They Don't)
Rider feedback on Best Ever pads is definitely mixed, which shows just how personal saddle pad choice can be. Many users are incredibly loyal, with one enthusiastically sharing, "The Best Ever pads really are the best! I have 3 now, and they are my go-to pad!" These riders often praise the pad's fit, comfort, and performance. However, other customers have been left disappointed, citing issues with quality control. One rider described receiving a pad that felt "super super thin cheap feeling." This highlights that while many have a five-star experience, there seems to be some inconsistency in the final product.
What's the Price Tag (and How Can You Save)?
Let’s talk about the elephant in the room: the price. Best Ever Pads are a premium product, and their price tag reflects that. But a higher price doesn't have to be a dealbreaker. Think of it as an investment in your horse's comfort and your own peace of mind. High-quality tack is designed to last for years, and when you break down the cost over its lifespan, it often makes more financial sense than replacing cheaper pads every season. Plus, there are several smart ways to shop that can make this top-tier gear more accessible. From seasonal sales to shipping deals, a little planning can go a long way in getting the best value for your money.
Understanding the Price Range
When you start shopping for a Best Ever Pad, you'll see prices that can go up to $350, with liners costing around $30. This range covers everything from their standard pads to fully customized creations with unique leather and designs. The cost is a direct reflection of the premium materials, like high-density wool, and the fact that each pad is handmade in the USA. While it's a significant purchase, it's priced in line with other top-tier saddle pad brands that prioritize quality craftsmanship and materials designed for your horse's ultimate comfort and performance.
Finding Deals and Holiday Sales
If you have your heart set on a Best Ever Pad but want to find a better price, patience is your best friend. The company often runs holiday promotions and seasonal sales, especially around events like Black Friday. During these sales, you can typically find discounts from 10% to 25% off, which can make a big difference on a higher-priced item. The best way to stay in the loop is to follow their social media or sign up for their newsletter so you get a heads-up when a promotion is about to drop.
Taking Advantage of Free Shipping
Shipping costs can add a hefty amount to your final total, so it's always wise to look for free shipping offers. While Best Ever Pads offers free shipping on US orders over $500, that's a pretty high threshold. A better option is to shop with an authorized retailer like Hooves and Paws. We offer free shipping on all orders in the continental U.S. with no minimum purchase required. That means you can get your new horse tack delivered right to your door without worrying about extra fees, whether you're buying one pad or outfitting your entire barn.
Why It's an Investment That Pays Off
Ultimately, buying a Best Ever Pad is about more than just the initial cost—it's about long-term value. These pads are built to withstand the demands of daily riding. The primary material, wool, is a powerhouse of performance; it’s breathable, wicks away moisture to keep your horse's back cool, and is surprisingly easy to clean. You can find more details on their FAQ page. Investing in a durable, well-made pad protects your horse's back, improves saddle fit, and can even enhance performance. When you choose quality gear that lasts, you're making a smart investment that pays off ride after ride.
How to Choose the Right Best Ever Pad for Your Horse
Picking the right saddle pad is one of the most important decisions you can make for your horse's comfort and performance. A great pad distributes pressure evenly, wicks away sweat, and protects your horse's back. But with so many options, how do you know which one is the perfect match? Best Ever Pads simplifies this by offering distinct collections tailored to different needs, so you can find the ideal fit for your horse and your riding style.
Whether you're a casual trail rider, a competitive barrel racer, or have a horse with a tricky-to-fit back, there’s a pad designed with you in mind. Thinking about your horse’s conformation, your saddle’s fit, and the demands of your discipline will point you in the right direction. Let’s walk through the main collections to see which one sounds like the best fit for your partner.
The Original All-Arounder: The OG Collection
If you need a reliable, do-it-all workhorse of a pad, the OG Collection is your answer. This is the original Best Ever Pad, crafted from 100% needle-punched wool that creates a firm, durable, and breathable foundation. It’s an excellent choice for everyday riding and a wide range of disciplines because it holds its shape and provides consistent support without being too bulky. Available in a classic dark gray, you can choose between a 3/4" or 1" thickness depending on how much protection your horse needs under the saddle. For most riders and horses, the OG is the perfect, no-fuss starting point for quality and performance.
For Added Comfort: The Kush Collection
Does your horse need a little extra softness and support? The Kush Collection is designed for exactly that. Made from 100% washed and pressed wool, these pads are incredibly soft and flexible right from the start. They do a fantastic job of absorbing moisture and conforming to your horse’s back, providing superior comfort during long rides or intense work. The Kush pad is a great option for sensitive horses, those with minor back soreness, or anyone who wants to give their horse a more luxurious feel under the saddle. It comes in a light gray color and is available in 3/4", 1", or 1.25" thicknesses.
For Hard-to-Fit Horses: The CEO Collection
Finding the right horse tack can be a real challenge for horses with unique conformation, like high withers or a sway back. The CEO Collection is the solution. These pads are specifically engineered with built-in features to address common fitting issues. Some pads in this collection include special foam inserts or soft fleece to fill in gaps, lift the saddle, and provide targeted support where it’s needed most. If you’ve struggled with saddle fit and keeping your horse comfortable, the specialized design of a CEO pad can make a world of difference, ensuring better pressure distribution and a happier horse.
Matching the Pad to Your Horse and Discipline
Once you’ve narrowed down the collection, getting the size right is the final step. A simple way to find the correct length is to measure your saddle’s skirt and add two to three inches. This ensures you have enough pad coverage in the front and back without excess bulk. If you’re still on the fence, Best Ever Pads offers free fitting assistance, which is a huge plus. You can text or email them photos of your horse’s back, both with and without a saddle, and their team will give you a personalized recommendation. This level of support helps ensure you invest in a pad that truly works for you and your horse.
What if It's Not the Perfect Fit? Understanding the Return Policy
Investing in a quality saddle pad is a big decision, and you want to feel confident that it’s the right choice for you and your horse. If you’re on the fence, knowing the return policy can make all the difference. Best Ever Pads has a straightforward process if things don’t work out, which is always a good sign. It shows they stand behind their products and want their customers to be happy. Let’s walk through what you can expect if you need to make a return or an exchange.
The 90-Day Full Refund Window
Here’s the deal: Best Ever Pads offers a generous 90-day return policy for a full refund if you’re not completely satisfied. You’ll need your receipt, and the refund will be for the full amount minus the shipping costs. This gives you plenty of time to decide if the pad is the right fit. One important thing to keep in mind is that this policy doesn’t apply to pads with customized logos or brand names. Because those are made just for you, they can’t be refunded. So, be sure to double-check all your custom details before you finalize your order.
Making an Exchange
Sometimes a refund isn't what you need—you just need a different pad. The good news is that exchanges are also an option. If you have an unused pad but misplaced the receipt, you can still exchange it for another item of the same or lesser value. Even better, if you’ve used the pad and find it isn’t fitting your horse correctly, you can exchange it for a different pad collection within that same 90-day window. This is a huge plus, as it gives you a real-world opportunity to test the fit and function where it matters most: on your horse.
How Their Policy Compares to Others
So, how does this stack up? A 90-day window is quite competitive in the world of horse tack and shows a strong belief in their product. The flexibility to exchange a used pad that doesn't fit is a standout feature that you don’t always see. The main limitation is the no-refund rule on custom work, which is fairly standard for personalized items but still something to be aware of. Here at Hooves and Paws, we believe in giving you complete peace of mind, which is why we offer our own 365-day satisfaction guarantee on the products we carry.
The Final Verdict: Are Best Ever Pads Worth It?
So, what’s the bottom line? Deciding if a Best Ever Pad is the right choice for you and your horse feels like a big commitment, and it is. It’s an investment in your horse’s comfort and your performance in the saddle. While the brand has a loyal following, it’s not without its critics. The truth is, there isn’t a simple yes or no answer. The value of a Best Ever Pad really comes down to your specific needs, your horse’s conformation, and what you prioritize in your gear. To help you make the best decision, let’s break down what fellow riders are saying about quality, performance, and when these pads truly shine.
A Note on Quality Control and Authenticity
One of the most common concerns you’ll hear from riders involves the consistency of the pads. Some customers have been disappointed to receive a pad that feels thinner or less substantial than they expected, leading them to question its quality. When you’re investing in premium equipment, you want to be confident you’re getting the real deal. This is why purchasing from an authorized retailer is so important. It ensures you receive an authentic product and have support if something isn’t right. At Hooves and Paws, we stand behind every product we sell with a 365-day satisfaction guarantee, giving you peace of mind with your purchase.
Performance: Expectation vs. Reality
When it comes to performance, opinions are split. Some riders feel the pads don’t hold up to rigorous, long-term use as well as some competitors, like 5 Star. They report issues with compression and durability over time. However, many other riders find that their Best Ever Pads perform beautifully, offering a great fit and excellent moisture-wicking properties for their horses. Performance often depends on the specific horse, the type of riding, and how the pad is cared for. What works perfectly for a weekend trail rider might not be the best fit for a competitive barrel racer, so consider your discipline and how much wear and tear your horse tack typically endures.
When a Best Ever Pad is the Right Choice
Despite the mixed feedback, there’s a reason so many riders are passionate about their Best Ever Pads. For many, these pads are the perfect solution. They are especially loved by riders who need a specific fit for a hard-to-fit horse or those who want to create a completely custom look. If you’ve struggled to find a pad that sits correctly on your horse’s back or if you love the idea of designing gear that reflects your personal style, this brand is hard to beat. For riders whose horses move comfortably and stay dry under these pads, they are absolutely worth the investment and quickly become a go-to piece of equipment in the tack room.
How to Care for Your Best Ever Pad
Investing in a quality saddle pad is an investment in your horse's comfort and performance. To get the most out of your Best Ever Pad, a little routine care is all it takes. Proper cleaning and storage will not only extend the life of your pad but also ensure it continues to provide the support and protection your horse needs for every ride. Think of it as simple maintenance for one of the most important pieces of your gear. Taking these small steps will keep your pad looking and feeling great for years to come.
Keeping Your Pad Clean
One of the best features of a Best Ever Pad is the high-quality wool, which is naturally breathable and fantastic at pulling sweat away from your horse’s back. This helps keep them cool and comfortable, but it also means your pad is absorbing a lot of grime. To keep it in top condition, regular cleaning is a must. Brushing off dirt and hair after each ride is a great habit to get into. For a deeper clean, you can gently hose it down and hang it to dry. This prevents the buildup of sweat and dirt, which can cause the wool fibers to become stiff and less effective over time. A clean pad is a comfortable pad.
Storing It the Right Way
How you store your pad between rides makes a big difference in its longevity. Tossing it in a heap on the floor is a recipe for a misshapen, mildewy mess. Instead, store your pad in a cool, dry place where it can breathe. You can lay it flat, wool-side up, or hang it over a saddle rack. The key is to avoid folding or creasing it, which can break down the fibers. It’s also important to know when a pad has done its job. Over time, the wool will compress where the saddle sits. Once it feels thin and packed down, it’s time to replace it to ensure your horse continues to get the cushioning they need.
Tips to Make Your Pad Last
Want to maximize the lifespan of your pad? A few proactive habits can make all the difference. First, if your horse has unique conformation, like high withers or a sway back, consider a pad from the CEO Collection. These are designed with extra support built right in, which can lead to more even wear. Second, be vigilant about checking for compressed wool. Continuing to use a worn-out pad can impact your horse's comfort and performance, so replacing it on time is a key part of your overall horse tack maintenance. Finally, if you’re ordering a custom pad, remember to plan ahead. Simple custom options can take a couple of weeks, while more intricate designs may take several months to create.
Where Can You Buy a Best Ever Pad?
Once you’ve decided a Best Ever Pad is the right choice for you and your horse, the next step is figuring out where to get one. You have a couple of great options, each with its own set of benefits. Whether you’re looking for a fully custom design or need a reliable pad shipped to you fast, here’s what you need to know to make the best purchase.
Buying from the Official Website
If you have a very specific vision for your saddle pad, going directly to the source is your best bet. The official Best Ever Pads website is the place to go for full customization. You can design your pad from the ground up, choosing everything from the leather color to custom embroidery and logos. Because these saddle pads are handmade in the USA to your exact specifications, you’ll get a truly one-of-a-kind piece. This is the ideal route for riders who want to perfectly match their tack or add a personal brand to their gear. Just be prepared for a longer wait time while your custom pad is being crafted.
Why Shop with an Authorized Retailer like Hooves and Paws
For riders who need a top-quality pad without the wait, an authorized retailer is the way to go. When you shop with us at Hooves and Paws, every Best Ever Pad you see is in stock and ready to head out the door today. We offer free, same-day shipping so you can get your new pad fast. Plus, you get the benefit of our 30 years of expertise and our unbeatable 365-day satisfaction guarantee. If you don’t see the exact style you’re looking for in our collection of horse tack, just let us know. We can often special order it for you, giving you the best of both worlds.
What to Know Before You Buy
Before you click "add to cart," it's smart to know the return policy. If you buy a standard pad directly from the manufacturer, they offer a 90-day window for a full refund, minus the shipping costs. However, it’s crucial to remember that any customized pads with logos or brands are considered final sale and cannot be returned. Be sure to double-check all your details before submitting a custom order. This is one reason many riders prefer shopping with us. We stand behind every product we sell with our own 365-day satisfaction guarantee, giving you a full year of peace of mind with your purchase.
Related Articles
- Top 7 Saddle Pad Picks for Comfort and Performance 2025
- Professional's Choice Mesquite Saddle Pad | 100% New Zealand Wool | 1"
Frequently Asked Questions
How long will a Best Ever Pad actually last? The lifespan of your pad really depends on how often you ride and how you care for it. For a rider who trains daily, the pad will naturally show wear faster than one used for weekend trail rides. While some riders feel they don't have the same rugged longevity as denser pads, you can greatly extend its life with proper care. Regularly brushing off dirt and storing it correctly will keep the wool performing its best for years.
Which collection is the right starting point for my horse? The best way to decide is to think about your horse's specific needs. The OG Collection is a fantastic all-around choice for most horses and disciplines—it's a reliable workhorse. If your horse is sensitive or could use a little extra cushion, the softer Kush Collection is an excellent option. For horses with tricky conformations like high withers or a sway back, the CEO Collection is specifically designed to provide targeted support and improve fit.
Can I just throw my pad in the washing machine? Please don't! Machine washing can damage the wool fibers, causing them to break down and lose their shape and supportive qualities. The best way to clean your pad is to brush it regularly to remove hair and dirt. For a deeper clean, you can gently hose it down with cold water and hang it to air dry completely, away from direct sunlight.
Will a Best Ever Pad fix my poor saddle fit? A high-quality pad can certainly improve comfort and help with minor fit issues by distributing pressure more evenly. However, a pad is not a cure for a saddle that truly doesn't fit your horse. If your saddle is causing pinching, bridging, or soreness, your first step should always be to work with a professional saddle fitter. A good pad is meant to complement a well-fitting saddle, not correct a bad one.
How long does it take to receive a custom pad? The timeline for a custom pad can vary quite a bit. If you're ordering a pad with simple customizations, like a specific leather color, you might receive it in a few weeks. For more intricate designs involving detailed tooling, hand-painting, or embroidery, you should plan for a longer wait, potentially several months. It's always a good idea to order well in advance if you need it for a specific show or event.
